Hiya, Fluffsters.
Somebody came up with a fan theory that supposedly connects Disney’s “Beauty and the Beast” with “Aladdin”. The theory is that Belle’s book is referring to Aladdin. The theory was popular enough that it even made a “trending” tag on Facebook. And got a “distractify” article. And other attention.
They cite the lines “Far off places, daring swordfights, magic spells, and a prince in disguise!” and “Here’s where she meets Prince Charming, but she won’t discover that it’s him ’til chapter 3!” as evidence.
My response:
No.
That is PLAINLY false.
The entire point of Aladdin is that he’s in disguise as a prince. He is not a prince in disguise. I don’t think Aladdin ever qualifies as Prince Charming, actually. He never truly becomes a prince, because the Sultan decrees that Jasmine (and any princess) can marry whoever she pleases. Aladdin also wishes Genie free, instead of becoming a prince.
SO THE ENTIRE PREMISE IS WRONG.
Furthermore, it’s always been clear that the book Belle is reading actually has a lot more to do with her own story. She meets a legitimate Prince Charming who is (somewhat) in disguise, and doesn’t realize it until the third act. She’s basically reading her own story!
And if it has to refer to a different Disney Movie, then Sleeping Beauty works at least as well. It takes place in England. That’s relatively far off, compared to provincial France, where Belle is. (Ok, so it’s not as far as Aladdin. But it’s still a ways away.)
Concerning swordfights: The prince fights a dragon with a sword. If that doesn’t count as daring, I don’t know what does.
(As a friendly reminder, I don’t recall Aladdin actually doing much sword fighting, either. He wins by using his non-princely street-smarts.)
Next, “Sleeping Beauty” definitely has magic spells. The entire premise is built around magic spells.
Finally, and more to the point, it has a prince in disguise.
Prince Charming comes waltzing into her life, but she doesn’t realize who it is.
But, he is still a prince.
FROM THE BEGINNING.
And that is actually one of the plot-points of the movie. Unlike Aladdin, where the plot-point is still the reverse.
So, the fan theory does not work.
Any questions?